Scripto | Revision Difference | Transcription

1904-10 Rex vs. Wong On and Wong Gow – murder (at the Chinese theatre)

GR-0419.100.1904-10p030.jpg

Revision as of Dec 12, 2016, 2:16:08 PM
created by 172.16.1.125		 Revision as of Dec 13, 2016, 10:44:17 AM
edited by Rbcm.admin
Line 1: Line 1:
−
  Into a persecutor for pecuniar purposes.
+
23:
−
MR POWELL:   Did----
+
 
−
COURT:     That question is withdrawn, and if it is on the notes   it can be struck off——
+
into a persecutor for pecuniary purposes.
−
Q       After they went in to Quann's room that night these four or five fellows,  did anyone come in ?
+
 
−
MR TAYLOR:     I object to that.     It is also a leading question— Did anyone come in.         My learned friend must have some fairness about this, at least he must be guided by the ordinary principles of law.
+
Mr. Powell: Did -
−
MR. POWELL:'    Is Your Honor going to stand this I merely asked hlm the question Did anyone come in ? MR. TAYLOR:       It is a leading: question. MR, POWELL:     I would like to have a ruling on that, before we have a long speech.
+
 
−
MR, TAYLOR:     My learned friend is entitled to ask him what occurred, but not to lead this witness along piecemeal.       He is asking a leading question and I submit that my learned friend is not entitled to nurse this witness over the tender spots; he is entitled to ask him where he was on that evening, and what occurred, but he is not entitled to ask him a leading question such as this——-
+
Court: That question is withdrawn, and if it is on the notes it can be struck off -
−
MR. POWELL:       Would your Honor give a ruling on that.     I asked him if anyone came in after they were there ?
+
 
−
MR. TAYLOR:     That is leading. MR POWELL:     We have heard your objection; surely, the court is entitled to give an opinion on it.
+
Q After they went in to Quann's room that night these four or five fellows,  did anyone come in?
−
COURT:     I do not think it is every question that requires Yes or N0 for an answer that is a leading question.     I do not think there is anything ____________________----------------------------•—-------—
+
 
−
BC Archives GR-0419       BRITISH COLUMBIA. ATTORNEY GENERAL. Box 100 File 1904/10        Attorney General documents.
+
Mr. Taylor: I object to that. It is also a leading question - Did anyone come in. My learned friend must have some fairness about this, at least he must be guided by the ordinary principles of law.
 +
 
 +
Mr. Powell: Is Your Honor going to stand this I merely asked him the question Did anyone come in?
 +
 
 +
Mr. Taylor: It is a leading question.
 +
 
 +
Mr. Powell: I would like to have a ruling on that, before we have a long speech.
 +
 
 +
Mr. Taylor: My learned friend is entitled to ask him what occurred, but not to lead this witness along piecemeal. He is asking a leading question and I submit that my learned friend is not entitled to nurse this witness over the tender spots; he is entitled to ask him where he was on that evening, and what occurred, but he is not entitled to ask him a leading question such as this -
 +
 
 +
Mr. Powell: Would your Honor give a ruling on that. I asked him if anyone came in after they were there?
 +
 
 +
Mr. Taylor: That is leading.
 +
 
 +
Mr. Powell: We have heard your objection; surely, the court is entitled to give an opinion on it.
 +
 
 +
Court: I do not think it is every question that requires yes or no for an answer that is a leading question. I do not think there is anything
 +
 
 +
BC Archives GR-0419 Box 100 File 1904/10 / BRITISH COLUMBIA. ATTORNEY GENERAL. / Attorney General documents.

Revision as of Dec 13, 2016, 10:44:17 AM

23:

into a persecutor for pecuniary purposes.

Mr. Powell: Did -

Court: That question is withdrawn, and if it is on the notes it can be struck off -

Q After they went in to Quann's room that night these four or five fellows, did anyone come in?

Mr. Taylor: I object to that. It is also a leading question - Did anyone come in. My learned friend must have some fairness about this, at least he must be guided by the ordinary principles of law.

Mr. Powell: Is Your Honor going to stand this I merely asked him the question Did anyone come in?

Mr. Taylor: It is a leading question.

Mr. Powell: I would like to have a ruling on that, before we have a long speech.

Mr. Taylor: My learned friend is entitled to ask him what occurred, but not to lead this witness along piecemeal. He is asking a leading question and I submit that my learned friend is not entitled to nurse this witness over the tender spots; he is entitled to ask him where he was on that evening, and what occurred, but he is not entitled to ask him a leading question such as this -

Mr. Powell: Would your Honor give a ruling on that. I asked him if anyone came in after they were there?

Mr. Taylor: That is leading.

Mr. Powell: We have heard your objection; surely, the court is entitled to give an opinion on it.

Court: I do not think it is every question that requires yes or no for an answer that is a leading question. I do not think there is anything

BC Archives GR-0419 Box 100 File 1904/10 / BRITISH COLUMBIA. ATTORNEY GENERAL. / Attorney General documents.