-9-

There was no fight at all until Ing Soo picked up the chair. I heard no demand for pay by Ing Soo. I did not hear Spencer call Ingo Soo a son of a bitch but will not swear that he didn’t.

There was no blow struck before the Chinaman picked up the chair. I did not interfere.

The above evidence is taken in the presence and hearing of the accused.

(Sgd) Thomas Lakin.

(Sgd) Arthur B. Fenwick, J.P.

(Sgd) R.L.T. Galbraith, J.P.